In a comment thread on Scatterplot, Neal Caren pines “I wish there was an arxiv.org for the social sciences.” I wish this as well! I am still shocked that economics is light years ahead of sociology on circulating working papers (e.g. NBER, IZA discussion papers, people just posting nice LaTeX’d versions on their personal academic sites, etc.). Kevin Bryan of A Fine Theorem links to an ungated version of every Econ paper he reviews – and notes wistfully the lack of such papers when he touches on Sociology.
So, my question is, what would it take to make a social science arXiv happen? What if instead of founding the next journal, a group of editors/scholars got together – perhaps with the backing of a scholarly publishing office of a University amenable to such things?* – and put something like this together. Perhaps relatedly, why is SSRN not like arXiv for the social sciences? What is it missing – is it just a lack of norms of posting working papers there, or some key features around commenting, etc.?
*arXiv.org is hosted by Cornell, for example.